One of those rare academic articles delivered as a poem: Brodey waxing lyrical about family therapy.
A family is a growing thing,
Sit and watch the rhythms of
its dance,
An Analyst, who tries to
read the system
of exchange.
And they too shift
and change before one’s eyes, as
tempers flare and angry eyebrows
Flatten into hurt feelings as one asks:
“Is every one in this
family angry—or have
you no language to
separate anger from wanting to reach out,
and meet again.”
And some families
never meet, and,
contact is a thing
they long to have. And so
they substitute words
and signs and symbols—
Hollow lectures to
adolescent children
which the therapist
records and plays
back the recording.
And father
listens
to his voice
While he hears
mother
gently crying
and really asked by father’s eyes,
She gives corrective information:
“I could not tell you
what an ass you have
become—
Pulpiting
my boys.” And father replies:
“I was not aware”
And father, children
even therapist feel
the living affection
waiting in this
family group,
drifted apart
in a circle of
father’s work:
he doesn’t know
the children:
nor listen:
so they are no
fun:
He doesn’t tell
them: and his
wife takes over:
not because she
wants to.
She’s Aggressive Dominant type,”
the psychologist
said—
But he is too, at his
office and at home
the more he
reached for closeness the
more
afraid
of:
no she needed
only his
money
to
raise
the
boys.
Contact: That’s a
whole theory.
Out of contact is
of course psychotic
or preoccupied
by inner workings—
Privacy is
necessary.
But in contact
what do I mean.
In contact
means to acting with
eyes linked
in hate love
indifference.
A family therapist
is not in favor of
divorce or
marriage.
He is in favor
of a family
being aware
of its own
existence
Not as what
should be, but what it is now.
The Should-be Family is
out of contact
With what?
Each other as they
pass through time,
or stages of development.
A baby still at seven,
he wets his bed.
“He shouldn’t doctor
what should I do?”
And a dried-up father
sits by muttering
his Aphorisms like
prayers waiting for
responsive readings
from his children.
One pee’s his bed
The other slicks
his hair back
sweet and
does the way he
“ought to” for his friends.
There’s a piece of
classification. The
Should and Ought-to
families who
raise the Doctor to
his Dais—to
judge or gentle
super ego
masochistic
compulsive
tendencies.
It’s all his fault
the family always
knew and
whatever the
Doctor says is
just to verify!
The doctor who
is a family therapist
listens.
He comments to
The family in his
room, on their
system of operation
He delights in bringing to the family’s
awareness
Its non-verbal gestures which
defeat and contradict and cross.
And silent fists are
heard in father’s slowly
rhythmed gentle tones
and the boy’s hate
twists his mouth
while he answers yes.
The family therapist
is a communications
expert. He must
get through.
Translate from
one generation to
another.
No, not interpret
but make them
aware they speak
a different
language.
The Americanized
Puerto Rican boy
may have no
family that understands except
his own gang—
his brothers
The parents are
police.
And gangs
make
feelings that are
strong enough to
be like what they
were in another
generation. At home.
Put them there
before you Papa
Mama Joe the
Kid
And analyze their
system
Their contact
with each other
and where it
broke down. As a family.
So there’s one
kind of family that’s
healthier and another
that’s more sick.
yes! Socially
why not, but there’s
Different styles of living
and
educating kids
For different
ways of living in
a different kind of
worlds.
Now if you want it simple
categorize linear style:
There’s one way that's
best. And one’s
mature, and one’s the cause—
a kind of germ—The ma
who done it
to
Schizophrenic
Panics. They
all have
Simple names.
But they are not
simple people.
And who’s the
most productive?
Each culture
has its system
And split level
paper thin
houses rhythm
a family’s
biology
and
change
the
culture.
A visit to the home
will open a therapist
to the bedroom story
of props
and who takes out the garbage.
The Family Therapist
knows the biological
world– Territoriality
is not a strange word.
Crowd people up and
the stink and noise
gets them unless
trained to it.
A family trains
its
kids to be Artists
Schizophrenics
And good guys
How?
Try to understand the family
while it’s still going on.
Work with a family.
Watch a family together
as they teach the littlest
one how far in your
office they can
Roam. How far to stand apart.
Do they breathe
Italian or
Pennsylvania
style.
The upper class family
sits at my desk
sharpening my
pencils and the
lower class kids
overawed don’t
say much and it’s
not that they are quiet.
The parents taught them long ago
“Why won’t you talk?” the parents
say.
But with kids I’m
glad the parents are there
I don’t need their secrets
I just want to know
what’s going on.
They tell me by their actions
what they don’t know in words.
Usually their
fighting–
crescendo builds
contagion
they want
me to decide whose right
I say
“You don’t even understand
what you are saying
in your household–
a tower of babble
crazy mixed up
talk.
Let’s stop!
What did your
wife mean. She
said “you don’t
understand and you all
defend
without
listening.”
The therapist listens softly
they talk to each other
She says
“He’s like driving a
car without
a destination.”
“I always get the shopping done”
Is he passive?
She defends her destination
by a list of
notes–yes she
brings them to the
hour to know what to say.
And her husband remarks
“I let her run the
house” but he
doesn’t
nothing works.
Now how does
this family operate
so as to avoid
anything but
misery. That
takes Art.
The Family
Therapist may
be joined in
his curiosity by the husband.
The children learn a new perspec-
tive—
Mother’s ways are odd. So what?
Father agrees with what they thought.
At last.
The therapist has no
place as the
sick child supporter
or the Dutch Uncle
He is not a family
Counselor or a
marriage Counselor
This is psychiatric
business with an organization.
If you
don’t from the
first speak to a
family as a
whole you’re
lost!
“What do I mean?—
Johnny stutters, doctor,
shall I bring him in,” she
says to the phone
“Bring in the whole family”
“Grandma too?”
“Of course—she lives with you?”
“You say
live
She
runs
the
house.”
Watch what this family
does with its language
—makes noises with
words and speaks
so the boy if he
tries to say
anything
is in the middle of
a breath
well it’s all just
wrong!
Learning language
is an intricate
affair—the
Rhythm is wrong
they jerk in their
dance nothing
flows. Mama
taught him
to speak so
he wouldn’t be
like father.
The more intricate
learnings must
be taught
by example.
Teach a child
to be Honest
as a Virtue—a little crook
Tell the little girl
to beware of strangers—she
pays attention to the shadiest
characters.
In the Family therapy
you watch the problem
in process the
children being
taught and teaching
their parents to
be sick or well.
Researchers
no longer have to
use their symbolic
logic and infer
and infer
Watch castration
in process—father looking daggers at
son stroking mama’s leg for comfort.
Watch the girl
being primed for
an accident which
will need an abortion
And don’t be
ashamed
to refer to mamma’s
own secret
feelings. Shh. they are known
family secrets
make sense
out of so much
the children have
partly learned
at last
learning
is
acknowledged,
Even if still unsaid.
“It’s too personal
When you are
older
I will
say
it.”
At last.
It’s in the
open
it’s a
secret.
What is the process of
Family Treatment:
A Family works at
its problems together
Papa selected Ma
because she seemed
right to him—intuition
love
A kind of matching that
can reinforce
Problems or Assets
of the last generation.
A new foreground
Background shuffle.
It isn’t just addition
or Averaging.
This couple when they
meet each other
just explode into
feelings which
elope with them
Sensible enough.
And the way they organize
Their children
Program them
Before they learn
to talk and later
is different than
a group of friends
or of patients
even when they
select each other.
Marriage is a
different kind of
selection.
They say married people get
to look alike.
Child rearing is
Information exchange
And Contact is between
the way your children
are and the way
that you and your parents
organized each other.
A little of the message sent returns
to correct the next bit so
It can approach
correct
its error
contact
Cybernetics, Ethology, Information
Theory
Analysis
converge.
The process of
family treatment
is making aware
what is so accommodated, or
so intrinsically repetitive
as to be unknown to
yourself but not the
other.
The therapist’s work is contact. They
meet each other and themselves
and they may
decide that they
couldn’t care less
and disengage.
Only one thing to say
more and I must
stop and summarize.
The Aztecs didn’t
bury their garbage
for the Archeologists
to find, The Rain
dancers don’t make
with phallic symbols
Their feet
just dance
Retrospective theory
that says a family
is this way because they
want to accomplish
some purpose, is a perspective
in the mind of the
observer, which
makes sense
for journal presentations.
The nuance of the therapeutic
artist as he opens outward
To touch a new unknown
Stirs the creativity of the
family’s world
Watch a family, work with
one
Why has family therapy been
avoided
in the past
Remember it’s man’s
first institution.
Look what happened
when a single man
was analyzed
inside
by
Freud.
No! who studies
intercourse between
two people and their family
institution.
It’s too damn close
to home!
Too damn simple
that’s why it makes
you anxious,
I am a man my
skin is my boundary
don’t you know!
A signal emitter a
receiver a feedback
circuit. A system
of emission, input
put it in, smell, sound,
light vibrations,
tissue. No!
How mechanical
can you get!
And changing over
time—regenerating
one generation to the
next No!
No it all ends with
me Do individual therapy.
Family therapy spans
the generations
makes its unit
a living organ
made of
living cells,
What!
A family has a skin
its own kind of filter
Any daughter-in-law
will tell you.
Obsolescence is the curse
of Orthodoxy
Family Therapy opens
A new way of
moving out
It presents a
psychology of
growth
of multiplying
self reinforcement
Two people
catching fire
create
learning children
coded
beyond either
ones
control.
A family is a living
thing,
a creature,
spanning
time.
And of the
families I
have worked
with
Some are glad
I have come
So close
to
Home